Should my air conditioning be on heat or auto mode in winter?

Author:
Dr. Julian Carter

This post explains whether heat mode or auto mode works better in winter. It covers how auto mode makes decisions, why it often causes cold air, and which setting gives more reliable heating during colder months.

You want warmth.
You want simple settings.
Auto mode sounds right.

In winter, auto mode often causes more problems than it solves. Many cold room complaints come from systems left in auto when heating is the real goal. The system behaves logically, but not in the way you expect.

What auto mode actually does

Auto mode does not lock the system into heating.

It constantly decides whether to heat or cool based on sensor readings. Those sensors sit close to the indoor unit. They react to local temperature changes, not how the whole room feels.

The system is always making decisions.
Those decisions do not always match comfort.

Why auto mode causes cold air in winter

In winter, small temperature changes matter more.

Sunlight through a window
Cooking
People in the room
Appliances running

These can briefly raise the temperature near the sensor. Auto mode may respond by reducing heat or switching to cooling for short periods.

That is when cold air appears.

Why heat mode behaves differently

Heat mode locks the system into heating only.

It ignores short temperature spikes.
It focuses on maintaining warmth.
It runs more steadily.

For winter use, this creates more predictable comfort.

Heat mode removes the guesswork.

When auto mode feels especially unreliable

Auto mode causes the most problems in these situations.

South facing rooms with sunlight
Open plan spaces
Rooms with large windows
Homes with multiple heat sources
Spaces used at different times of day

In these cases, the system keeps changing its mind.

How to tell which mode you are using

Check the controller display.

Heat mode usually shows
A sun symbol
The word HEAT

Auto mode usually shows
The word AUTO
Both heat and cool symbols
Changing icons

If AUTO appears anywhere, the system is still deciding for you.

Why changing the temperature does not fix auto mode

Raising the temperature does not override auto mode logic.

The system may still cool if it believes the room exceeds the target. This often surprises users who think the temperature setting forces heating.

Mode always comes first.
Temperature comes second.

Fan speed makes auto mode worse

Fan speed changes how sensors react.

High fan speed moves air across sensors faster. This exaggerates temperature swings. Auto mode responds more aggressively as a result.

This creates cycling.
Cycling creates discomfort.

Heat mode reduces this behaviour.

When auto mode can work acceptably

Auto mode can work in limited cases.

Well insulated homes
Small rooms
Stable temperatures
Minimal sunlight variation

Even then, it rarely improves comfort compared to heat mode.

Common winter mistakes linked to auto mode

These come up repeatedly during support visits.

Auto mode left on from autumn
Heating expected without checking mode
Temperature adjusted repeatedly
Fan speed changed constantly
Timers combined with auto mode

Each one increases confusion.

Best winter setting for most homes

For winter use, a simple approach works best.

Select heat mode.
Set a sensible temperature.
Use medium fan speed initially.
Allow 10 to 15 minutes for the room to warm.

This gives stable comfort with fewer surprises.

When mode choice is not the issue

If heat mode is active and the room still feels cold after 15 minutes, the issue may sit elsewhere.

Possible causes include
System sized mainly for cooling
Low outdoor temperatures
High heat loss from the building
Restricted airflow

These need assessment.

When to seek professional support

Contact a specialist if
Heat mode is active with no improvement
The system switches modes unexpectedly
Error codes appear
The outdoor unit does not run during heating

Before calling, note the controller type, model number, and what the display shows.

This helps speed up diagnosis.

Related guidance

Further residential air conditioning guidance is available at
https://www.climateworks.co.uk/residential-air-conditioning

References

UK Government guidance on heat pump operation
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/heat-pumps-how-they-work

Building Regulations Approved Document L
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/conservation-of-fuel-and-power-approved-document-l

ClimateWorks residential usage data from installations across Hampshire, Berkshire, Surrey, and Oxfordshire between 2022 and 2025

Author

Dr Julian Carter
Technical and Compliance Director
ClimateWorks

Dr Julian Carter has over 20 years of experience in building services engineering, air conditioning system design, and regulatory compliance. He advises on residential and commercial projects across the UK, covering system selection, installation standards, commissioning, and real world performance.

As Technical and Compliance Director at ClimateWorks, he oversees technical governance, installer training, fault diagnosis, and customer education. His work focuses on reducing user related issues, improving system reliability, and ensuring air conditioning systems perform consistently throughout their service life.

Get a fast no obligation quote today
Icon

explore recent blogs